I have so many mixed feelings about this book, I am kind of stuck on where to start. My classmate and I were talking about how a book would not be THAT hard to read despite Professor O’Malley’s many, many warnings to us about how dense and difficult it was. I found myself getting distracted quite easily and I am not sure if that was because of the book OR (this had me thinking about earlier in the semester and distracted me even more) because of the ideas from our first book, “The Shallows” by Carr and my attention span is not good. I thought it was funny and ironic in a way that the ideas from one book were proven while trying to read another. I could not tell you or anyone how many times I read a page and came to the realization that I had no idea what I just read; my eyes read the words but my brain didn’t comprehend. There was so much information thrown at us and it was completely overwhelming. Overall, the book was awful and I never want to read again.
Our discussion in class however was much more stimulating. For me, as I’m sure it was for everyone else, the decerebrating of the cat was the most uncomfortable and disturbing part. It really stumps me when scientists and researchers think that cats were a form of communication. I know back then science was not as advanced as it is today but is that really an “excuse”? I even tried to get a visual of it by Googling images, but there was nothing (sort of relieved). The cat piano/organ was something that also caught my attention. Yes, not killing animals but they were still being abused. I was curious about how the cat piano work and came across an article that states the tails were pulled when a key was pressed. This worried me because cat’s tails contain nerves and if their tails are injured, it can cause permanent damage. But there was no evidence on the conditions of the cats.
In Chapter 6, Is Music Still A Thing?, the quote “Is music a thing? If it was, is it still?” caught my eye for a second. This brought me back to a discussion we had when Professor O’Malley was demonstrating how to use GarageBand. All sounds and instruments are now digitalized and not 100% natural which kind of ruins the purpose of creating music. There is no purpose in learning how to play a piano, saxophone, drums, etc. when one can just use their computer keyboard for a note. So, although music still exists, it also doesn’t. Music that is not pure and real can be considered fake, and it’s true value and quality is taken away.